Showing posts with label vampires. Show all posts
Showing posts with label vampires. Show all posts

Thursday, 7 September 2017

No Moon To Pray To by Jerry Guern

No Moon To Pray To. 

It has been thirteen years since the Fourth Crusade captured Constantinople. Father Michael has spent those years exterminating the supernatural creatures that once infested the city. Shortly after returning home to Provence, he stumbles upon a nest of vampires, creatures his order believed they had driven from Europe. Alone and cut off from his brother hunters, he turns to Enik, an ageing knight tormented by guilt over his actions in the Crusade. For them both to survive, Michael must initiate Enik into spiritually dangerous supernatural secrets that his order has guarded for centuries. He will also learn that the penitent knight and a centuries-old vampire know secrets that his own order kept hidden from him.

The Guru's Review: 

I was captured by the premise of this story. This seemed to be a different take on the usual vampire lore. One that I found very pleasing and refreshing. The author has not set out to glorify vampires or promote their dark origins or the romantic aspect (that I could never understand), but rather to show the spiritual side of this topic.

Right from the first few pages, I was hooked. I had to know more and where the author was going with this story. Normally a prologue is not particularly riveting despite it setting the background to the novel or giving some basic details that will be relevant to the plot later on. In this novel, the prologue is the hook that becomes embedded in your curiosity to read more and want to know more. Another characteristic of this prologue is its striking beauty. It is a touching account of Jesus carrying the Cross to Golgotha. It nearly had me in tears. Despite this beauty, Guern introduces an evil character who offers Jesus a proposal that is similar to the one offered by Satan when Jesus was in the wilderness. I loved Jesus reply to this character and how even then, He stated His purpose in continuing on with His mission to be the propitiation for man's sin. This has an effect on this tempting character that I did not realise the importance of until much later. I had to pause after this prologue as I wanted to reflect on this account. It could definitely be a short story on its own. It showcases the talent of this author.

If anything, this prologue shows that this author wrote this novel to adhere to biblical principles. It either gives a glimpse of what the relationship the author has with Jesus or that he intends to base this novel on biblical principles showing this spiritual side of vampirism. Or both. And this despite it being from a Catholic background and very much a Catholic flavour. I found this interesting and refreshing as most Catholic flavoured novels promote more Catholicism than the doctrines or principles of the Bible or Catholicism's relative, Christianity. My apologies here as I come from a Catholic upbringing and my disillusionment with this denomination shows in my conversion to Christianity since. That is why I say this novel is refreshing and pleasantly surprising from an author I presume is Catholic. Or he is not but has just convincingly written this novel reflecting the Catholic bent that is based on the Catholic church's attitude to the time of the Crusades to these demonic entities and their methods of removal.

From the first chapter when we are introduced to the main protagonist, Father Michael of Galen, and the exorcism he performs, the hook becomes further embedded in the reader's curiosity. Now the reader must know who is this priest and why he is so special. As you progress in the novel and the plot unravels, you become more intrigued about the passion and motive that drives this man to eradicate this vermin he considers vampires to be.  You start to wonder where his special abilities or powers come from. Are these endowed from God or another source? Is Michael human, angelic, demonic or some other entity? Despite this mystery, you find yourself on his side and cheering him on in his quest to eradicate Christendom of the vampiric curse. 

Guern introduces Michael's past in a flash back format that also serves to provide many backgrounds to the plot arcs. These include those of the Crusades, especially the almost failed Fourth Crusade, the motives and attitudes of the Church to these Crusades, the other protagonist, Enik, his background in the Crusades and becoming a Knight. Interspersed in this are the secretive order that Michael belongs to and his mentor, Father Rannulf and their torturous relationship. At times, I found these flash backs a bit tedious and very detailed but if you persist, you not only see more evidence of the more than competent story telling ability of this author but you also see that in the long run all these details come together and form a unique and solid background to the world building Guern creates so masterfully. And it is this that is one of the wonders of this novel and of this author. 

You hit the ground running with this novel. The pace may slow somewhat during these flashback and background building scenes, but these, despite their sometimes tedious nature, still manage to keep you interested and focussed as you know the author is going to return you to the present where Michael and Enik are desperately trying to fight the nest of vampires in Enik's home town on Marse. It is here in this plot arc that we discover more of Michal's past and its connection with one vampire in particular who is highlighted as the main antagonist. Despite him being a vampire, I found myself extremely curious as to his background, his motives to know more about Michael, his past and his motive for wanting to kill him and his cohort. You definitely realise that there is a deeper plot/story arc that this vampire is involved in and as the novel progresses, this becomes a platform for every other plot arcs to be brought into alignment contributing to a most unexpected but satisfying conclusion. 

But even then, just when you think Guern has tied up all the loose ends, you realise that one major plot and character arc is left unsatisfactorily unresolved. Then you start to consider that after this novel being so masterfully constructed, why would the author leave you in the dark on such an issue. Your final thought on this? This has to be addressed in a sequel! Not only that, but there are also other plot arcs that relate to Michael and his connection to one notorious Cardinal Graziani. I can say that the way this novel ends and its plot arcs are going to make for another suspenseful and action packed sequel, that will expand more on the events and world building created by this talented author.

What I found interesting apart from everything else in this novel, is Guern's take on the origin of vampires, the two vampire types, and how some who are turned can attain some form of control over this curse. This is explored in much more detail through the vampire antagonist I mentioned previously. This all ties in very well with the mission of the secret order that Michael belongs to and its mission. 
Then there is an ability that they possess that I have not found in any other vampire novel. They use this to their advantage in trying to defeat Michael and Enik until Michael shows them how to counteract this. A very clever ability to add to the vampire characteristics that we have come to know from the many novels in this genre.  

I have a soft spot for Enik. Guern has given him a very interesting and detailed past. He is one very committed believer in Christ and single handedly saves the Fourth Crusade which prepares the way for a Fifth. I admire him more than I do Michael. Despite Michael showing a strong commitment to the Catholic Church and his secret order, and a knowledge of God and Jesus and comes across as being a believer, it is Enik who is the real Christian character in this novel. His speech to his fellow Crusaders when Graziani has admitted defeat of this Crusade is very sincere and appears to be inspired by God. He shows repentance for his less than admirable motive to further the Crusade under Graziani's manipulation and even upon discharge from the Crusades, he returns with very Christian like behaviour in being a Lord to the peasants in his care in Marse. He finds new found strength as he takes on being a Knight again but this time with a stronger and deeper relationship with Christ and a very specific role in ridding Christendom of the vampire curse. I imagine Guern developing Enik further in future instalments and I look forward to this immensely. 


There is one issue that I am looking forward to seeing the author address. I cannot give away too much here as spoilers but I know it will either be addressed fully in the next instalment or developed further and continued in a possible third. In its unexplained status in this novel, I find it is the only thing that appears to conflict with the biblical/Christian principles the author has laid out. I am very curious to see the author's explanation. Such is what can happen with a novel's construction and author's strategy in constructing a novel and planning for further sequels.

I mentioned previously how this novel ends with a satisfying and unexpected ending. I loved it. It also sets the stage for further development of the biblical aspects of this novel. The theme of this ending is in line with a few other vampire novels written by Christian authors who have the same end result. In this novel, however, the journey to this result is different to the others but is no less satisfying, just a different slant of the theology of it. 


This is one very satisfying world that this author draws you into. His writing style is engaging and addictive. It is very appropriate to the style and flavour of the world building that depicts the 12 Century of the Crusades.

I look forward to the continuing saga of this series. It definitely appears that this author has so much more to say about what he has established so far. 


Strongly Recommended. 

To buy or preview this novel, click on the BUY/PREVIEW icons on the image below:

Tuesday, 28 March 2017

The Christian and the Vampire by Vikki Kestell


I have read this short story (34 pages, I think) three times now. The second time was because I did not write a review from the first reading. This third time is because I felt it needed to be honoured for the faith and redemptive fiction that it contains and how Kestell has applied the Word of God in the most appropriate way that is more than effective in witnessing and leading to a relationship with God to what some might say is a fictional being. But she also shows how this same Word of God can be applied to any human being who feels they are unredeemable. No wonder the Bible states that it is the power of God unto salvation (Romans 1:16) and that the power of God is sharper than a two-edged sword, penetrating as far as the separation of soul and spirit, joints and marrow. It is able to judge the ideas and thoughts of the heart. (Hebrews 4:12).

Based on the above, I have awarded Vikki Kestell with a Redemptive Fiction Award as this novel now meets The Reality Calling Christian Fiction Awards criteria. Please see the end of this review. 


What happens one sultry summer night when a Christian and a vampire meet on a fire escape and agree to engage in a cordial conversation? A touch of hilarity, plus eye-popping—and Undead heart-starting—revelation, as vampire myth and legend give way to greater Truth!

The Guru's Review:

This is the second time I have read The Christian and the Vampire and I did this for 2 reasons. One, I did not write a review of this when I read it in December 2014, and two, it is worth reading again purely for the way the story is structured to allow the many bible references and their explanation to move the story along and show the power of the Word and how it defeats all claims that being a follower of Satan (in this case, as a vampire) is more attractive and beneficial than being a follower of Christ. 

This is the third Christian story involving the question, "Can a vampire be saved/redeemed?" The first one I read was Blood for Blood by Ben Wolfe and the second was Devil's Pathway (DAWN: Warriors of Valor Book 1) by Vicki V Lucas. I do have another waiting to be read. All these three authors share the same premise that indeed they can be redeemed, and I would also say the same for werewolves. The latter has been dealt with in this same vein by William Woodall, in his The Last Werewolf Hunter: The Complete Series

Kestell has constructed this short very well with the placement of the bible verses that portray what the bible says about redemption, salvation, Christ's victory over sin and death, Satan's judgement, the penalty of sin, consequences of refusing Christ's gift of salvation in relation to Lambros being a vampire. Very cleverly done structuring the plot around the verses or is it that she constructed the verses around the plot? Hard to tell when it is done this well. It struck me that this short could be used to minister to a satanist or someone who is so very bound in their sin/sinful lifestyle and feels there is no hope for them including anything that God has to offer.

I guess another reason I wanted to read this again is that it reinforces where all Christians have come from, including myself; a past of sin, rebellion against God, and this short story shows what the bible says about our past and our future. It is always good to return to one's roots to appreciate where one has come from and where one is now. I have a greater appreciation of the Word, what Christ achieved for me on the Cross and everything relating to all the doctrines outlined in the previous paragraph.

Kestell uses humour to add spice to this short. It also adds to both the character building of Taz and Lambros. Kestell has also portrayed Taz as the discerning, well versed in Scripture, spiritual warrior that Christians all need to be as the whole essence of becoming a Christian means that we have taken one side against the other in this spiritual warfare that we are involved in.

Apart from the bible references that make this short rich in spiritual warfare, I loved how Taz was so in tune with the Spirit when ministering to Lambros. Again, this is another part of our spiritual armour. The final spiritual warfare scene at the end of the short involving a warrior angel and demon is very dramatic and I loved the way Taz states that he was not afraid of this tangible evil presence that descended on both Lambros and himself as he knew who he is in Christ and the protection that is his as a consequence of this, 
I felt no fear for myself - I am, after all, one of the redeemed of The Lord. Satan has no legal footing in my life.
I applaud Kestell for this short. I feel it is quite a masterpiece of construction, however simple. This story would be very effective for small group bible study on spiritual warfare and witnessing to those who are heavily involved in satanism or other satanic groups or as I mentioned previously, those who are so caught up in their sin and feel there is not hope for them or a way out. I would love to see a discussion guide added to a future edition of this short. 

One highlight that I found very useful is in the kindle version where each reference to a bible verse or piece of conversation that was based on a bible verse or doctrine, had a link to it that you could press and the verse would appear in a separate, mini window on the screen. This would benefit bible study groups or the individual that are seeking God. All the individual would have to do is put themselves in the position of Lambros, not as a vampire, but as one who is enslaved to sin and Satan as Lambros was.

This is one very entertaining, edifying but sobering read of spiritual warfare, who Christians are in Christ, what Christ has achieved for everyone on the Cross and the hope that exists in Him that is rife in His Word. 

Highly Recommended. 5/5 Stars


----------------------------------------------------------

Spiritually, based on my review and on the following reference booklet,

A Spiritual System for Rating Books by David Bergsland, and that The Christian and the Vampire contains elements of the criteria of what constitutes Christian Redemptive Fiction outlined in this booklet, (click on the title below to see what this is based on), I award Vikki Kestell with 


Christian Redemptive Fiction Award by Reality Calling






Congratulations, Vikki!



To read a preview or buy this novel, click on the BUY or PREVIEW icons below.


Tuesday, 4 August 2015

Isaiah: The Spirit of the Tree (Isaiah Tiller Book 2) by Andrew Simmons



It was very late in the evening and the sky above the glass-covered garden was dark, as the moon had already set. The garden was very peaceful for Ichiro Katsumi as he walked the main path near a small babbling stream. A few moments later, he settled on an old wooden bench beside the running brook. The sound of the moving water always helped him to relax, so he closed his eyes and rested his head for a few minutes. Soon the beeping of his watch told him he needed to return to his late night work. He stood up and stretched as his ear caught the faint sound of singing drifting on a non-apparent breeze. 

“Where is that coming from?” he wondered to himself aloud as he strained to listen. 

Ichiro’s curiosity caught the better of him as he walked toward the soft melody. He followed the man-made brook and came upon a Japanese maiden dressed in a full kimono sitting at the water’s edge. She had a basket of Japanese pears on the ground next to her and was singing ever so softly. Ichiro watched from behind a bush for a few minutes before he decided it was time to present himself. 

“Excuse me young lady, but may I be of some help to you?” he asked in Japanese as he stepped into the open. The maiden focused her attention on Ichiro as she gracefully stood to her feet. Her singing grew louder and completely mesmerised Ichiro. She held out her arms and he started walking toward her. His face displayed total bliss as he found himself wrapped in her outstretched arms. She raised her lips up to his and they kissed. Tears of joy streamed down his face as the magic of the moment touched his soul. Then without warning, it was replaced by pain as tree roots erupted out of the ground and dug their way into Ichiro’s legs. He tried to scream, but he could not pull his lips off hers. His body shook violently as the roots made their way up into his abdomen. Ichiro ceased to struggle when they pierced his heart. The maiden let go of him and he fell to the ground, his dead eyes open wide in terror and blood dripping from his mouth. She continued to sing the hauntingly beautiful song with her blood red lips as she disappeared into the garden. 

The Guru's Review: 

Any reader is going to be in a very opportune position when they discover a series that has either some or all of the series already published. It is even better when, on top of this, the series is one action packed, attention-grabbing, cannot put down, all absorbing and thoroughly enjoyable read. Such is the case with the Isaiah Tiller series. 

After finishing Book 1, I just had to read Book 2 and it was such a joy to have this available. The only downside to this is that I have to wait up to six months for Book 3 to be released and how Book 2 ends, I am very eager to read this next instalment.

Simmons has constructed this series with an ongoing storyline from Book 1 interspersed throughout the action of this instalment and it gives the impression that this not only enhances and add layers of suspense to this instalment but also provides further continuation of all these in preparation for Book 3. It does not detract from this book's storyline and the flow between the two is very smooth and seamless. A very clever technique. So if any reader of Book 1 has any questions about Deena and the rivalry between the Jahai and the Valcarda families and the associated subplots, and more about the vampire hierarchy, then keep reading! With every new chapter, I found myself wondering if I was going to get more of this book's story line or more of the continuation from the last book! Kept me guessing and I liked this feature very much. 

This instalment shows more of the demon entities that the Hunters, as Isaiah calls his team, fight. We have the same weapons as in Book 1, but this time Isaiah fights ghouls and an evil spirit. Again we have the reliance on God by Isaiah and how he comes humbly before God for strength, guidance and discernment. This time however, Isaiah may have met his match as the supernatural entity he fights is one formidable opponent and he nearly succumbs to its power, but as usual he has it all worked out in preparation before this confrontation. Simmons has even introduced a touch of romance for Isaiah! Despite this being 71 pages, the suspense, action and all the clues are lined up and very nicely tied up very tightly. I love the log book entries that he includes in each book, his case notes if you like. Reminds me of the Captain's log that Captain Picard from Star Trek has in each episode. This closes off very nicely these instalments. I also love this spiritual warfare, special ops type environment and Simmons creates and develops this extremely well. The blend of these genres at first glance one would not consider they could ever form a compatible marriage, and yet they do. 

I admire Simmonds talent for writing, characterisation and plot construction. I would love to see him write a full-length novel in the future. If this series is giving him confidence and refining his craft, then all I can say is his future novels are going to be well worth reading and supporting. 

I sincerely hope that Simmons has no delays in preparing Book 3 for release as I cannot wait to see what he presents us with next. 

If any reader liked the first instalment, they will love this second one. It will sit extremely well between Books 1 and 3. 

Highly Recommended. 

Sunday, 2 August 2015

Isaiah: And the Night is Gray (Isaiah Tiller, Book 1) by Andrew Simmons



After his wife Deena was attacked by a vampire, Pastor Isaiah Tiller sets his old life aside to become a hunter of the very thing which took his wife from him. Isaiah threw himself into his physical, mental, and spiritual training and then when he was ready, Isaiah slowly began his exploration into the dark underworld which destroyed his life. Soon, his investigation would bring him face to face with his own failure from the past which had haunted him for years: his deceased wife and the vampire which turned her. 


The Guru's Review: 

I chose this book to buy for one reason only. I was intrigued with the concept of a pastor being a vampire hunter! I considered this would be a fun read. It definitely fits into the edgy, Christian, speculative fiction genre. 

Looking at this author's background I am not surprised that this short (71 pages) turned out to be a fast paced, action packed, pocket rocket! I love it when an author successfully packs a lot into such a short word/page limit. The other factor that makes this such a successful short is the background of the author. In his own words,
15 year animation veteran from the Walt Disney Animation Studio in Orlando, FL. I worked on most of the animated movies from The Little Mermaid, the Lion King, to Brother Bear doing various jobs as: Cel Painter, Traditional Film Camera, and Final Check.
During my time in the field of animation, I spent many hours learning exactly how Disney went about telling a story. I was able to watch film stories grow and refine as the process of completing the film went along. Soon I started writing and developing my own ideas and stories and Isaiah Tiller is one of the many ideas to come out of my time at Disney.
Simmons has a unique background to write this series and it definitely shows in this short. What also intrigued me about this series, is his development of the vampires and his world building as described by Tom Bancroft in the foreword, 
Somehow, Andrew had created a world where you could have a cool, tough, and spirit-filled hero who knows something that most in this world do not-that demons are real and they can take many forms. They can even take the forms of myths and legends so it is possible that - in this world at least-werewolves and vampires exist. And not the wimpy, gorgeous male vampires that read poetry and romance women more than they suck blood - these are horrible, death-bringing monsters. And forget all the wooden stakes and silver bullets - it's really about your faith in an all -powerful God that will defeat those horrors! What? That's right; Andrew Simmons has found a fresh and new angle to tell stories with vampires and werewolves that no one has been brave enough - or sincere enough - to try. 
Too bad this is in the foreword, if this was part of the blurb, then this would have been enough for me to buy this short. Simmons has created a story that grabs you and does not let go until the end. It reads like a movie and I am not surprised seeing the background Simmons has come from as described previously. 

I love the structure of the bounty hunter world. Isaiah Tiller is a Pastor who seeks to destroy the vampire that turned his wife. He belongs to a group of fellow bounty hunters, all Christians, who report to another Pastor who co-ordinates their activities and sets their assignments in breaking up this mafia type vampire empire. Within this empire there are two ruling families, the Jahai and the Valcarda and it is the Jahai family who want to expand their empire and I guess, in doing so dominate the Valcarda family. 

Within this world building, Simmons has given a brief outline of vampire folklore. There is the status level a vampire has to attain first before turning a human into a vampire, or else the turned will be a lesser type of vampire, there is the rogue status of vampire and finally how to kill a vampire. There seems to be two methods of doing this, one purely by physical means (and not the wooden cross or silver bullet either), the other by spiritual. Of course, Tiller employs the spiritual means by way of using the heightened senses that the Spirit gives him to detect their presence, the Word of God, prayer and the use of "holy" water consecrated by God. He also uses various weapons and combat warfare in fighting them. Simmons adds a further spiritual aspect, through Isaiah, in the redemption of vampires, as he says to his turned/vampire wife, 
......everyone deserves a chance at redemption, even a vampire
This possibility of redemption seems to be a common theme in vampire fiction written by Christian authors. This same theme runs through Ben Wolf's Blood for Blood, Vicki Lucas' Devil's Pathway (DAWN: Warriors of Valor Book 1) and Vikki Kessler's The Christian and the Vampire: A Short Story.

I like what Simmons has to say about the whole story of Isaiah Tiller and him being a vampire hunter: 
The concept for Isaiah Tiller started when I was gaming some Call of Cthulhu with a local group I used to play with years ago. I wanted to play a character which stood up for what I believed in, even if it was just a game world. Well, I created an ex-pastor that went around destroying evil. The game character ended up dying in one session, but I enjoyed the idea so much I resurrected the character in one of my first short stories. I have spent the last fifteen plus years refining the idea. If I was to describe the essence of Isaiah and what one can expect when reading his adventures, it would be this: one part faith, one part action, and one part classics monsters with a modern twist.
Simmons definitely portrays Isaiah as someone who stands up for what he believes in. You can see that it is this conviction plus his faith in God and obedience to Him that provides his motivation to be vampire hunter. At first I thought that he was mainly motivated by revenge for his wife being turned, but at one stage where his attempt at killing Gray fails, he repents for fighting in his own strength and asks His help to rely on God instead. Important lesson in spiritual warfare. 

This is one well crafted and very unique concept. I like what I have read here and I am now a devotee to this series. I am glad Book 2 is released as I can now get into this. Book 3 will be released in a few months time. 


Highly Recommended.

Saturday, 27 June 2015

Crazy Moon (Lou's Bar & Grill, Book 1) by Frank B. Luke



Welcome to Lou's Bar & Grill where the house special looks like a bargain but will cost more than you think. Lou and his staff have everything a person could want, and they know the best way to present it to you.
After being stood up, werewolf fanatic Laney McMurphy went to Lou's to forget her sorrows. To her surprise, Lou offered her a place in the local pack. To progress within the pack's ranks, she'll have to give in to her wild side. And most importantly, she'll have to indulge her wrath. Each victory means a step up in rank. What she knows about wolves will help. What she doesn't know just might get her killed.

The Guru's Review: 

Every since reading Blood for Blood by Ben Wolf, The Last Werewolf Hunter: The Complete Series by William Woodall and Devil's Pathway (DAWN: Warriors of Valor Book 1) by Vicki V. Lucas, I have become more curious in seeing how Christian authors treat the subject of vampires and werewolves from the Christian/biblical worldview. These authors have treated this subject very well, all very plausible and well grounded in the Biblical perspective from this worldview.

I came across Crazy Moon by Frank B. Luke from him being one of the newest authors who joined The Crossover Alliance that I am involved in. I knew this to be a short story, all 23 pages long, so was not surprised it took close to an hour to read.

I found this to be a fun read! Yes, there is the killing that goes with werewolves and vampires (not graphic) but that is avoidable with this subject matter, but I was more interested in the spiritual side of this plot. In one sense I was disappointed in that there is none to see except that it outlines the contract established between the devil (yes, satan) and the main character, Laney, and that by agreeing to become a werewolf, this means she has sold her soul to the devil and an eternity in Hell. It would have been nice to have had it balanced a bit more with the other side of this spiritual doctrine, that is, whether there is any chance of redemption such as is portrayed in the Blood for Blood novel, The Last Werewolf Hunter series and alluded to in The Devil's Pathway novel previously mentioned.

At first I was annoyed that this had not been established but then realised that there is only so much that can be packed into a short story of this length. Based on this, I do hope that Luke investigates this more in future shorts in this series. It would be good to see what Luke comes up with from this Christian/biblical worldview. 

My only criticism is that despite Laney intrigued and fascinated with everything to do with werewolves from the media, and its folklore, she is portrayed as accepting too easily Lou's offer of becoming a werewolf without much thought of the spiritual side of it. As Luke explains, 
Just the standard contract I've been offering for centuries. Your soul upon death for becoming a werewolf until then.

I knew it, she muttered. If you're the Devil, there's a catch.

Everything is spelled out in black and white. Laney, whether you sign or not, upon death, you will enter the afterlife and go to one of two destinations. I am amassing an army for the war that will follow the end of the world. If you take my offer, you can be an officer in that army.

The contract looked solid, and she couldn't spot any loopholes for him to exploit. She signed her name with flourish.
I am also hoping that Luke expands more of this plot line in future shorts. If he does, then this series shows encouraging scope in both these plot lines from a biblical worldview.The other reason I say this is that Luke is described in his bio as writing, 
fantasy and science fiction to explore God's truth in fantastic ways. He finds such story-theology connects with readers on both cognitive and emotional levels. 
Strongly Recommended.