Showing posts with label Christian epic fantasy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Christian epic fantasy. Show all posts

Sunday, 28 August 2022

Guest Post: Ryan David Gerard and the Challenge of Depicting Christian Fiction Realistically.

I featured Ryan David Gerard on 31/08/19 in another blog, now defunct. 

Today’s guest is novelist Ryan David Gerard. His trilogy, The Baptist is one very edgy, speculative and edge of your seat reading. Ryan explores in this post depicting Christian fiction realistically. It is an issue that Christian authors have battled with and readers have criticised authors for either not depicting it as such or for having done so! Where is the happy medium? Is there one?

Now Ryan, has a lot to say, so this post is lengthy, but if you are interested in this topic, read on and be patient with Ryan! He delivers! He raises some valid and controversial points; I can vouch for these as I have experienced what he describes below in his novels.

Definitely grab a coffee or preferred beverage and dive in here. Let’s go! Over to you, Ryan!

The Baptist is a book series that is a modern-day reimagining of biblical events. In the near future, a time travel experiment goes wrong and an anomaly in the space-time continuum creates a time shift where history is jumbled up and certain biblical time periods happen in our day in age as if for the first time ever…In this modern setting, God and the devil agree to a cosmic rematch for the souls of humanity when the devil thinks he can defeat Christ if he had a second shot.  In the midst of all this, one rogue cop must battle his way through street crime and evil on a larger scale as life and the human condition hangs in the balance.

This series is written specifically for the world, not the church.  It’s not a typical, wholesome piece of Christian media.  It comes with one of those “explicit content” warnings on it. There is violence, in lots of police-action-style shooting and fight scenes and there is language. Because it’s all about the human condition, it is not a very pleasant subject matter. There are prostitution and drugs as well as gang and criminal activity.  None of the characters is Christian and, as such, they are written that way. It’s a story about how the rest of the world goes through life, popular beliefs about how good and evil should be handled, and how the average citizen would deal with God showing up in their life.

So as a Christian, I wanted to write a story that would not just be for Christians as most Christian media is if we’re honest with ourselves.  I guess I reached a point where I saw how ineffective Christian media was—now…let me pause because I want to clarify: I’m not saying that Christian media isn’t useful.  It’s good, wholesome entertainment for kids; it’s good for sermon illustrations or bible study type stuff for youth groups or anything that is within the church, for teaching and possibly strengthening believers—music especially!  I’m not saying it doesn’t have its place…it does. But here’s the real kick behind my writing: I was honestly tired of hearing all my friends say how much they didn’t like church and how cheesy, annoying and lame Christian media is.  The worst part, I came to realize, was that this wasn’t coming out of a place of defence, but because I really couldn’t disagree with them…the production values are poor, the acting is bad, the dialogue is worse because it’s written very carefully to be safe and non-offensive, therefore it’s unrealistic, the situations are likewise and unrealistic, the characters’; reactions are disingenuous, even when they try to be “:…and show a little anger or passion or something, it’s unbelievable, the music sounds like Full House”—I could go on…basically I find it grossly unrealistic and therefore not relatable.

The bottom line is that I thought to myself; “Why can’t Christians put out a better product—a more realistic, gritty, raw and unvarnished piece of media?  A well written and well-produced story, and wouldn’t it be awesome to not worry about being safe” or “So I began to realize that I should be the one to produce something like this, instead of waiting and criticizing.”

Now, I’m not naive enough to think that I am the only Christian who’s ever lived to think and feel this way–do a bit of research and you’ll find many groups and cliques out there–but I think what happens is that other authors write a rough manuscript, with the desire to be more gritty and raw as I’ve been illustrating, but then second guess themselves and begin to edit everything out! Anything potentially offensive or “and I think you’d find their intentions in doing so are not as pure as you would think”.  How do I know this? Because this was me. I am just as guilty of trying to please the church and have had this false sense of obligation to the Christian religion when my only obligation is to God and honouring Him.  My intentions, when editing all the “garbage” out of my books, were based on fear of what my church friends would think of me for writing them and not because I didn’t think the content would really make an impactful statement.  I heard their voices in my head asking, ‘how I could call myself a Christian if I wrote a book like this?’ One of the promotional posters I made for this series was a mock 80s/90s style gimmick poster. It mimicked the poster for Big Trouble in Little China and it included a lot of pop culture easter eggs (because I’m a pop culture nerd). 



Anyway, the poster brandishes a couple of controversial taglines. One is, “The Greatest Story Ever Told, Like You’ve Never Seen it Before”, and the other reads, “Welcome to the Bible, Baby!” (a parody of Guns ‘n Roses Welcome to the Jungle).  This was to portray a kind of sense that the Bible really is a wild story, full of action and drama, contrary to most belief that it is a boring and stuffy rulebook about clouds and sheep and all things good and wholesome.  If you do a google image search of “The Bible” or “Jesus”; I’ll get a bunch of pictures of those old romantic paintings with the sainted faces, or pictures of the bible and holy, praying hands or something.

The Bible is a no holds barred, epic story about the worst evil villain, to top all evil villains, attacking the prized treasure of his enemy, in the ultimate betrayal, causing a chain reaction of events that ripple down into the state of the world and sin and the human condition. Then, after a long exile and when it’s seemed as though evil has won, the fearless hero comes after his enemy, in defence of his beloved, and he kicks his ass!! He mops the floor with him, but not before being broken, beaten and bloodied, fighting through to rescue the girl (us) and restore justice to the world. It’s no mambie-pambie story, and neither is He! Read the description of Him in Revelation when He comes riding on a horse, wearing a robe drenched in blood and blazing eyes! He’s a badass!! And it’s the most epic of revenge and rescue stories to ever happen! That was the intention around my poster but as I was releasing it I admittedly cringed because I’m still fearful of the voices saying, “How can you blaspheme the Bible like this and portray it as this violent and gritty story, and portray John the Baptist as a violent man, with blood on his shirt and holding a gun?” The Bible is supposed to be all about peace and love and charity and selflessness, and all that…

1. The character in the book is not actually the real John the Baptist.  He’s a comparison.
2. The Bible is all about love and all that. 

But it is also full of war and violence, betrayal, sexually perverted societies, murder, and every evil thing under the sun.  Love is the final outcome and the main message, in spite of society and in spite of a hateful world. It’s about all that and how we overcome it. Every character in the history of the book is a loser, nobody, outcast, reject, failure, and on some occasions evil person, and they are all offered salvation, through…what?…the most violent and gruesome form of torturous death and through the blood!

Our freedom was won through great tribulation and war, as outlined for us in Revelation.  It talks about multitudes of angels and demons battling in heaven, great beasts out of the earth and sea, about the great dragon ready to devour Mary’s baby, and about the same dragon being defeated and hurled into hell! Also…it is just a poster, and I obviously do not believe that the Bible should be done over again. The images are meant to be an illustration of everything mentioned above. I am trying to make a statement, but it is simply satirical, to make a point, that if you want a good action story…

I know my books turn heads and raise eyebrows and I honestly am terrified of “making it big” or my books growing in popularity because of the controversy I know it will cause in Christian circles.  It’s still safe for right now, tucked away in my little pocket and only kind of out there on a small scale. But I’d love it to grow and spread and be celebrated and loved by everyone, and debated over.  But it scares me. On the other hand, I am also terrified of being discovered as being a Christian in the spotlight because of how the world does hate Christianity, but I should not be scared of the world and I think it’s time to try something different.  Something new, that breaks some rules but hopefully breaks down some walls and builds some bridges and opportunities. It’s time the Christian world put out something that people we claim to love have something real to relate to.  We have enough edification in our circles to keep us going, and more will be produced, but we need to put stuff out that actually impacts the world around us and doesn’t become a piece of the Christian clubhouse library.  Something that a real person would pick up off a shelf and want to read.

My books are about a bunch of regular, real people, unpolished and raw, and how they react to evil and the human condition and how they might react to the Bible unfolding in front of their eyes today!  I couldn’t write that story with safe language and clean content. These characters are dealing with deep and dark feelings, wrestling through profound situations and battling inner demons. When that happens, it’s not pleasant language and it’s not nice thoughts.  Anyone going through something hard will tell you that being holy isn’t the first thing on their mind while they’re going through it. I get it, and I know most Christian media is meant to shine as an example of how we should respond, an example of how it is possible to react differently, how biblical values should and can be applied to difficult situations, yes!  I get it…but there is also so much failure and heartache and beating of chests in between all the times we get it right.

In real life we often don’t respond the way we are supposed to, and the moment we don’t respond the way Kirk Cameron or Mr Whitaker does is usually when the outside world says our media is B.S., or we’re B.S., but that’s another topic…again, I don’t think Christian media does not have its place, but I want to put stuff out there for adults that is realistic, relatable, provocative, and impactful.  I’ve seen some Christian media outlets try to accomplish this but still fall short because you can tell by watching/reading/listening to it, that they’ve edited and censored the content to remain safe.

For anyone who is feeling conflicted about this style of writing, or worried that if you’d like to write unhinged, but feel like you’re somehow dishonouring God, don’t.  Even though I wrote a gritty, raw, unpolished story, I was very careful about how I wrote about God. The characters all make horrible decisions and they all fall and stumble and fail miserably as they go through the events, as we all do!  But I strictly used the scriptures and did my best to honour His character and emulate the love and patience and overall integrity of what I know, believe and adore about Him.  Everyone else?… I just wrote them as real people. How I observe everyone around me act and speak, and how I am a lot of the time, to be completely honest. here’s a scene in the books where the characters figure out who the Christ character is, and in their excitement they go, “Oh-ho”; and then they stop short, realizing they just swore in front of God, and apologize profusely, but the Christ character just patiently smirks and then the two of them share a vulnerable laugh about the whole situation.  

The world just needs to see that Christians are real people, and we’re not polished and carefully written, holy characters, or least that by writing something like this, it can show we are connected to the world and not removed from it; that we live in the real world with them and understand it, that we understand and can relate to the things that are hard, that we don’t believe things are a fairy tale and sit up on high horses, that we are in the trenches right along with them, that we are part of the grime and the grit that is life. That just like every other human, we are trying to find our way through the human condition and that we all commonly share one enemy of life and that we are all in this together! Not removed…because I guarantee if you ask anyone else what they think about Christians it’ll be all the opposite of everything above.



Going back to what I was saying about editing and censoring, I am not suggesting that we all have to let loose and write a rampage of foul language and gory content. We don’t have to go full tilt and write a Scorsese or Tarantino style book (although I do appreciate both filmmakers and their work).  All I’m really saying is, write real characters, facing real and raw situations. 

When they react to hurtful things or experience hardship, just write them real…think about how you would respond, before you stop and think of that popular 90s WWJD, think about how most normal human beings might feel, and then write that…make it real!  If the character has to say “damn”, let him say it. Let your characters fail miserably when they are challenged. Let your characters be weak.  Don’t edit everything out of your book because, “oh, that’s just not very Christian”. In my book, none of the characters are Christian so why would they do Christian things?  And if you’re writing Christian characters only in Christian settings and only acting Christian all the time, then your book is for the church, and that’s fine, but don’t expect anyone else to want to read it.  The thing is, we want people to enjoy our stories and we want them to impact people, but as soon as you lose your audience because your writing is too cheap then it’s too late, if they’ve even bought your book in the first place. People want to read something they can connect with and relate to. They want to read complex and flawed characters. You can still honour God and write imperfect people going through imperfect situations. Make the focus of your story, ultimately, redemption and salvation. Don’t curse or slander God’s character. 

Speaking of Quentin Tarantino, his Oscar-winning screenplay for Pulp Fiction goes down in history for being violent and chocked full of colourful language, and I’m neither condoning it or condemning it, but it’s a film all about gangsters and seedy people from the criminal underworld. On the surface, it may seem like an awful, nasty story, but if you can get past the language and some of the situations and Mr Tarantino himself has said this, the film is all about redemption. Every one of the characters is offered redemption, and even though it may not be spiritual, they are all offered a second chance.  There even is a large spiritual chunk when Samuel L. Jackson turns from a life of murder and crime and finds God.  And please don’t take that out of context. I’m not saying to look to Tarantino for theological purposes, but it just illustrates the point.  And sometimes we can just write, create or enjoy stories for what they are and not always have to be looking for the “Christian meaning”. It’s ok to like secular bands and enjoy secular movies.  I love the Avenger movies and all kinds of other movies without this whole, “what does this say about Christianity?” notion. Sometimes stories are just stories and entertainment. Write passionately, honestly and from the heart. Don’t take yourself too seriously that you miss the point.

Ryan has included an excerpt from the third novel in this trilogy, The Baptist: Revelation and his reason for including this: 

The following excerpt is taken out of the final instalment in my novel series. For context, the protagonist, John, has gone through the first two books trying to figure out the human condition and fix crime as a vigilante. He has fought and even killed in the name of good to reach this point in the story. Realizing that he was wrong in his methods, and after meeting the Christ character face-to-face, John is left feeling helpless to do anything about the grand scheme of evil itself in our world, besides some type of love in action. He had previously tried to convince his friends to join his fight, but at the time they didn’t understand things fully. At this point (and I’m not giving anything away, because most people know what happens to Jesus in the Bible) the Christ character has been killed and John is devastated. World War has broken out, and it’s pretty much the only option left, to go into the war-torn remnants of Washington D.C. and fight the devil himself and everyone who has chosen to side with him. John is still passionate enough to join the fight that’s now in front of them, but in this scene, he is arguing with his friend, where the roles have now reversed. I chose this scene because I think it reflects the gritty language and nature of the series, and it also highlights important points about sin, evil, choice, the human condition and how the world views these things. Enjoy!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Start of Excerpt ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Ridley sighed a huge sigh and looked at me, his face full of nostalgia. 

“I can’t believe you’re here man.”  He said warmly and he thudded my chest twice with his fist.

 “Me!?”  I replied.  “What about you guys!?”  I went on, gesturing towards him and G.

G slapped his hand on my shoulder from beside me and I looked at him.  

“We’re all happy to see you, brother.”  He said with a smile.  “And we’re all very lucky to be alive.”

I sighed and lowered my head.  “That we are.”  I said with a nod and I looked back and forth at both of them.  

There was a pause in our conversation now.  After telling all our stories and catching up, we were left with this moment.  A moment that allowed the reality of our current situation to seep back into our brains.  We looked at each other and our smiles began to fade and our eyes grew dimmer and more serious.

Thinking about my history with both of these men, I had a moment within myself.

“I never thought it would go down like this.”  I said.  “To be honest I never really had a clue how this would all end.”

 “Well you wanted to fight evil, bro.”  G said.  “Now you can.”

  “What’s the play anyways?”  I asked Ridley.  “Do we know where Ranston is?”

 “We have scouts who came back from D.C.”  He answered.  “And our group shares information with other cities.”

 “Wait” I said, “other cities?”

 “Yah.  Baltimore isn’t the only city affected by this war, John.  This is international.  This is global.  Everyone has some stake in this thing, and we’re all fighting the Lung in our own way.  Other cities are cooperating with us, even joining us.  We’ve been gathering Intel from everywhere.”

“And where does Ranston play into all of this?”  I asked.

“He’s the ring leader, man.”  Ridley answered.  “The whole world saw that…”  Ridley grew a little grimmer.  “…the day The Stranger died.”  He said sadly.

G and I both lowered our heads in remembrance.

“When he went on TV and declared himself.”  Ridley went on.  “He’s facilitated The Lung coming to America.  He’s backed them all the way.  But he’s gone into hiding since that day.”

“Yah, cuz he’s scared of us!”  G cut in angrily.  

I looked over and saw the confident sneer on his face.  “Is he though?”  I asked.  “Is he really, G?”  

G’s brow furrowed and he cocked his head.  

“If he’s really who we’re saying he is” I went on, “he’s the opposite side of a supernatural mega-force.  I mean, c’mon guys!  Why would he be scared of us?”

“Because of The Stranger!”  G said.

Ridley suddenly grabbed his arm and G looked over at him.  Ridley was looking at G like a parent looks at their child when they want them to keep their mouth shut.

“The Stranger!?”  I asked.  “He’s dead, G!”  

G settled down and he and Ridley looked away from each other.

“I watched Him on a TV and you two were right there with Him!”  I was raising my voice now and I cut myself off, taking a deep sigh.  I looked at the ground to compose myself.

“Look, Rid,”  I said slowly, still looking at the ground.  Then I looked up to go on.  “I’m with ya’ either way man.  You know that.  I stood up in that crowd for you and I’m with you!  No one wants to see Ranston go down more than me.  I just wanna make sure we’re not underestimating him, or…I hate to say it, playing into his hands.”

G and Ridley looked at each other and then back at me.  

“What do you mean?”  Ridley asked me.

“I mean are we really doing this?”  I began.  “Going to war?!  With the devil himself!?  And all those people…everyone that he and The Lung have recruited to their cause…we’re just gonna go and slaughter them all?!”

“This is war, John,”  Ridley said.  “People are gonna die.”

I was suddenly reminded of the conversation I had with Laz in prison about this.  But I also remembered something else.

“I remember something The Stranger told me,”  I said.  “A word.  Influence.  We’re all victims of it.  Most of the people they’ve recruited…they’re probably scared shitless.  The Lung gave them a pretty grim ultimatum and that’s their influence—I mean…don’t get me wrong; I hate evil!  I started all this to stop evil, but…everything I did…everything I stood for in the beginning was to protect and save people who couldn’t protect themselves…including against a terrorist threat like this.”

 I could tell from Ridley’s face that he was annoyed with my statement.

“So what are you saying then?”  He asked.

“Have we considered all our options?”  I asked.  “Is there another way we can do this?”

Ridley’s face was all screwed up now as he listened to me.  “John, when did you become such a bleeding heart!?”  He demanded to know.  

I rolled my eyes and looked away.

“What do you want to do?”  He went on.  “Peace and love, is that it!?  Is this the new John Revele!?”

“Rid…”  I began to interject.

“Save it, man!”  He hollered.  “Why did you even stand up in that crowd!?”

“Because I love you, Rid!”  I yelled.  “Because you’re my boy!”  I added, taking a step closer to him.  “We’re still partners, man.  All of us.”  I said, looking to G too, who smirked.

“Love…”  Ridley scoffed.  “So that’s the answer then is it?”

 I stared at him with pleading eyes and a long moment passed before he said anything.  Then he slowly shook his head.

 “Nah…”  He began.  “I don’t buy it.  It’s too easy.  It’s dismissive!”

“Dismissive?  How can you say that love is dismissive, after everything The Stranger taught us!?”

“Does it not seem like the easy way out to you?  When faced with real problems and hard situations, to just say; ‘ah, don’t worry’.  Are you gonna tell me that in my lifetime I could have just walked up to a drug addict or a prostitute and told them; ‘Hey, there’s a God and He loves you! He’s got a plan!’  and, what…they would then say; ‘oh!  Really!?  Are you serious!?  Wow, thanks for telling me, let me stop doing drugs right now, that makes all the difference in the world!’  No…they would probably laugh in my face and tell me to go fuck myself!”

“No.”  I said.  “You can’t just tell them that!  I loved Maggie, Rid!  I loved her myself, when no one else would!  And that saved her!”

Behind this, Maggie heard our words and tears rolled down her cheeks.  Clare listened on intently as well.

“Your actions saved her, John!”  Ridley said.  

“My love in action!”

Ridley rolled his eyes.  “Right…”  He said.  “So are we gonna love the terrorist army to death!?  What would you have me do, man?  March this army over to D.C. to give them all a hug!?”

“Pah!”  I passed my hand in the air at him and turned my back.

“And they’ll just lay their guns down and surrender?”  He went on.  “You used a word, now let me use another word.  A big one, John…choice!”

I sighed with my back to him and that word pierced my heart.  I looked to the ceiling with anguish as my thoughts conflicted.

“Choice!”  Ridley repeated.  “All those men who’ve sided with Ranston made their choices.  And we’ve made ours!  We’re standing here, on this side of the line!”

I closed my eyes now, allowing his words to seep in and infect me.  I couldn’t argue with him anymore.

“This is my love in action!”  Ridley went on.  “I’m making sure that people are safe again!  I’m making sure that love survives rather than hate!  Rather than evil, John…C’mon man!”

My friend was pleading with me—begging.  

 I agreed with him, I really did…

I guess I just needed the right push to side with him.

The right influence, To make the right choice.

“That’s Babylon out there!”  Ridley shouted.

My eyes now opened and he had my attention.

“Babylon, the great evil empire!”  He continued.

I lowered my head back down and saw Clare standing across the room.  She was staring at me.  She had written to me about Babylon falling.  Ridley and I used to talk about Babylon in the police cruiser.

“The Babylon, John!”  He said.  “This is it!  We go!”

I began to turn back around to face him.  

“We crush it!”  He said.  “We crush Ranston!”  His voice cracked with a sudden onset of pain, and I watched him stop himself short.  Ridley took a moment to compose but the tears came too quickly for him to hide, and several fell out of his eyes.  “I should’ve been there for Him, John.”  He forced out.  

I faced him completely now and stared back as he spoke.

“He wouldn’t have died.”  Ridley said, his voice full of remorse.

I shook my head.  “You would’ve died with Him, Rid.”  I told him.

“Then I would’ve died honourably.”

 I lowered my head and sighed.  

 “John…”  He went on.  “I can’t do nothing!  Not again.  If we have the chance to end it…we have to take it don’t we?”

There was a long pause between us before he spoke again.

“Babylon…”  He said.  “It’s predestined to fall.  You read it yourself.”

 My face broke into a chuckle and I looked away.  After a moment I looked at him again and he was smiling too.

 “We can’t lose.”  He said.  

The three of us stood there for a good long while more.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ End of Excerpt ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Ryan can be found at the following social media platforms: 

  Facebook: Renegades Creative  – Twitter –  Author website  –  Instagram  –  Pinterest 

For those who want to investigate more of this trilogy, Ryan has many videos and trailers about the characters, the novels and Ryan talking about its background. Click on the link below to be taken to his Video Gallery on his website: 

Book Trailers and Video Gallery

About Ryan David Gerard: 

My name is Ryan and I am a lifelong writer but first-time novelist. I am a husband and father of five, living in Ontario, Canada.

Though this is my first venture into the publishing world, I have always been a storyteller at heart. At a young age, I discovered my love of the movies and just had this urge to write stories and even produce my own movies with all my little buddies. It was just me and my imagination and a video camera back then.

All of my schooling background reflects creative arts in some way or another. I was accepted into the Visual Arts program in high school, which included sketching, painting and sculpting to name a few mediums. While going to school there, I became involved with the Audio/Visual team, which opened up a whole new medium of storytelling to me. It was the end of the nineties and going into the two-thousands which were spawning whole new technological advancements in amateur video production. Because of the opportunities that opened up in video production, I fell more in love with the type of medium and really started to focus my efforts in this field. It was fun! It was exciting! When I sat at the computer to either write my amateur scripts or edit a scene we had just filmed, it was sheer freedom! I could create whatever I wanted, despite what I was used to and what every English or Art teacher told me I couldn’t. English class for me, ironically enough (as an aspiring author), was one of those things that I wanted to like but just couldn’t. In theory, English was everything I wanted but I just found myself being bored. There were too many rules. Too many do’s and don’ts. In terms of storytelling, I always considered myself to be a little more unorthodox than the norm. If an artist can’t break the rules, just a little bit, then what’s the point of art?

So, after high school, I did two years of College in Saskatchewan. Without going into too much detail, it was a much-needed retreat away from my life in Ontario. While there, I studied video production and a little bit of sound design and music, though most of my time was spent sharpening my video skills. I met my wife there and we started our life together back in Ontario. We got married pretty quickly and a construction job was only a means to and ends for me. The plan was to work there for the time being, to pay the bills while I strove towards my goal of breaking into the film business. I even had several interviews down in the film district of Toronto at video production studios as an editor. Before I knew it five years had gone by and my dream was proving more and more difficult. The opportunity with my current job came around and with my wife and two daughters, a house and all that real-life stuff; I would have missed out on the incredible chance I had in front of me had I not taken it. I am thrilled that I accepted the offer, and I now work as a Special Constable, in law enforcement, for the city of Toronto. Not only is it a great and rewarding career, but it afforded me so much more valuable time with my family and also the means and time to start writing my story. The premise of it was something that was in my head from my teen years but I only then started to put pen to paper and begin creating this world of characters. I started writing in 2013 and actually finished the book’s first and very lengthy draft in 2014, which included three main sections or acts. Over the next few years until now, I was convinced to split the work into three separate novels and it has gone through extensive editing and revising on the advice and reads of other helpful people.

To buy or preview more of this series, click on the image below:



Readers and reviews are an author’s best asset, so I encourage any reader, to consider reading The Baptist Trilogy and submit a review on Goodreads, Amazon, Barnes and Noble and on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest (or any other social media you subscribe to).

Reviews help promote an author’s novel to potential readers and encourage the author to keep writing. Reviews also help get the author’s message (and God’s message) to the reader, whether Christian or not, who may need encouragement and support in their lives while being entertained by the story.

Please note: As an Amazon Associate, I am required to disclose that book cover images or titles of novels in this post are paid links if they are linked to Amazon and result in a sale.

Saturday, 13 August 2022

Novel Review: The Gathering Dark: (Quest of Fire, Book 1) by Brett Armstrong.

 I reviewed this novel on 01/01/20 in a previous blog, now defunct.

The Gathering Dark.

Jason is an expert at running from his past. But when it catches up, he finds himself hiding in a peculiar inn listening to a tale from centuries past.

The story is Anargen's, a teen who is pulled from all he loves to follow his oaths of loyalty to the fabled King of the Realms. Together with his mentor, Cinaed, he rides north on a special quest to mediate peace talks between ancient foes—the men of Ecthelowall and the dwarfs of Ordumair. Nothing goes as planned. Many on both sides of the dispute despise Anargen's Order. Worse, an arcane evil has returned to the North. This "Grey Scourge" seeks to ruin the peace talks and ensure a lost treasure held by the dwarfs is never found by those for whom it is meant.

As Anargen's story unfolds, Jason begins to wonder whether it is truly just a fable. He soon finds himself drawn into the conflict Anargen faced. A battle which has shaped and can destroy his world.

Perspective by Peter:

I’ve wanted to read this novel since its release and have now been able to due to being on holiday over Christmas and therefore have more time to squeeze it in without affecting my review schedule. The other reason is that his new release, Veiled Sun, the sequel to Day Moon (Tomorrow's Edge series) will be released on January 21 and I did not want to be behind in yet another novel for this author.

This was a very wise decision. I loved this novel and I pray the sequel is not too far away. At least in 2020? 

Having only read Day Moon, I feel that Armstrong is a better writer and creator of fantasy tomes than science fiction and futuristic ones. I loved Day Moon nevertheless. However, I have not read his other novel, Destitutio Quod Remissio set 4 years post-Jesus' resurrection (4 AD) so cannot say the same here. 

Maybe, fantasy is where he shines best. That would suit me as I do prefer fantasy above science fiction. The latter is still a favourite though. 

Armstrong has constructed this novel well. The worldbuilding forms a solid foundation for the plot, characterisation to be well embedded into. Everything springs forth from this. This adds to the success of an author where then they construct their novels on this principle. It adds credibility and depth. 

The characters have been developed to the point where they are relatable and earn the reader's endearment. You will love Anargen and share in his coming of age, his doubts, learning where he fits in, learning about love, being true to himself, standing up for what is right and true and his developing relationship with the High King. The reader will see Sir Cinead as a Gandalf type figure, with his sense of mystery and only revealing what needs to be known at that time, you will be endeared to him as well, you will regard Caesarus as an unknown quantity, wanting to do things his way, impetuous, impatient, but still loyal to the cause of being a Knight of the High King.

Armstrong is very competent at depicting the politics of warfare and conflict between regions or countries. He would make quite the diplomat in our reality. I am not very political and I was lost a few times in this depiction. But that is not a fault of Armstrong, he had that down pat, this was my deficit showing! This politics was another part of the worldbuilding and formed a believable and understandable basis of the war between the Ecthelowall and the dwarfs of Ordumair. 

Another aspect of a successful novelist is the depiction of fighting and warfare. Armstrong succeeds here. While I thought some of these were long, this was only because I like these to be of shorter duration, but that does not mean they should have been. Again, this is not a fault of the author's construction but of myself. These fight/warfare scenes play out in your mind as if you are watching a movie. It might be one thing to depict these scenes between humans and another when it is between different species such as humans and monsters. This adds another layer of complexity the author needs to deal with realistically. Armstrong deals with this well in his depiction of the Knights fighting the werebeasts and the Grey Scourge. I know warfare and fight scenes are the bane of authors, they either don't get it right or they do. Armstrong is in this latter category. 

Another pillar of this novel is the story within a story. The quest of the Knights of the High King to mediate peace talks between the two warring countries is told to Jason and others in an Inn in their real-time. Jason stumbled upon this storyteller Innkeeper when he enters Brackenburgh (Bracken in Anargen's day) on his mission to repay a debt. We are told nothing of this debut or its significance but I was not so concerned with this as to the significance of the Innkeeper. This adds a satisfying twist at the end where the tale of Anargen and the Knight's quest intersects with Jason and the Innkeeper. Unfortunately, I discovered this through a review on Amazon so this twist was not a surprise to me as it should have been and as planned by the author, but all this did was raise my curiosity as to how this occurs until I arrived at the end of the novel. This intersection lends itself very nicely to the continuation of this series in book 2, hopefully in 2020. It raises the question in this second novel, what is the connection between Jason and Anargen's tale seeing the latter occurred about 100 years before Jason is hearing about it? Also, why was the councilman so animated about the Innkeeper telling this tale and why did he take such drastic measures to have it stopped? 

Not much is explained about Jason. He is identified as a main character but the tale of Anargen and the Knights of the High King and their quest takes up the majority of the novel. However, enough is explained to keep your interest growing about him and his past. I look forward to this being further developed in the next instalments of this series. 

I know Armstrong not only reads for entertainment but for the deeper things he likes to see in his reading. What he yearns for is the spiritual specifically from a Christian/Biblical worldview. He writes from this worldview as well. This is evident in his novels. In The Gathering Dark, he has the Knights of the High King and their supernatural empowered Spiritswords.

Armstrong describes them as, 

The very words of the High King were inscribed upon it. No other sword had ever existed to be its equal. Though Anargen had never seen it or even tried to touch one, it was said when a Knight took hold of its hilt, the Spiritsword would take on a life of its own. Fire would catch on the blade and burn till released, though it neither burned the holder nor charred the sword or softened it. It was afire without being consumed.

To me, this description is very similar to the burning bush that Moses had to confront where God spoke to him. This fire that did not consume or burn is represented as God's Spirit here in both cases. Even the name Spiritsword hints to this. So this was a weapon used physically by the Knights but its end result or effectiveness was from the Holy Spirit. This reminds me of the verse in Zechariah 4:6 which states,  

So he answered me, “This is the word of the Lord to Zerubbabel: ‘Not by strength or by might, but by My Spirit,’ says the Lord of Hosts.

The other aspect of these Swords being of the Holy Spirit was that when they were being used, the Knight would hear instruction in their mind from the High King in avoiding the offensive actions of the werebeasts, Grey Scourge or the Ecthelowall. What did this do to the Knight? It encouraged them to trust and obey their High King and reinforce their loyalty to Him. These Swords were the sole effective weapon against the werebeasts and the Grey Scourge. Even the Ordumair acknowledged that none of their weapons were any match against them. But they were blind to the knowledge of the werebeasts being possessed by some demonic entity. I was reminded here of the Biblical truth that we need spiritual weapons to fight spiritual enemies as Ephesians 6: 12,

For our battle is not against flesh and blood, but against the rulers, against the authorities, against the world powers of this darkness, against the spiritual forces of evil in the heavens. 

There was one poignant account of Sir Cinead presenting the Knight armor to them and he explained the spiritual significance of the armour. I loved Armstrong's description of this armor. Specific to them as Knights of the Light. I was not surprised from this account that this armour would be based on the spiritual armor that is described in Ephesians 6:10-17,

Finally, be strengthened by the Lord and by His vast strength. Put on the full armor of God so that you can stand against the tactics of the Devil. For our battle is not against flesh and blood, but against the rulers, against the authorities, against the world powers of this darkness, against the spiritual forces of evil in the heavens. This is why you must take up the full armor of God, so that you may be able to resist in the evil day, and having prepared everything, to take your stand. Stand, therefore, with truth like a belt around your waist, righteousness like armor on your chest, and your feet sandaled with readiness for the gospel of peace. In every situation take the shield of faith, and with it you will be able to extinguish all the flaming arrows of the evil one. Take the helmet of salvation, and the sword of the Spirit, which is God’s word.

The Knights existed as a last remaining force representing the High King who used to rule across the Realms. With the peoples of these realms, such as the Ecthelowall and the Ordumair, falling away from the reign of the High King, the Knights were the last representative of the High King's rule and existence and their mandate was to reunite the peoples of the Realms to the High King. We see some very encouraging evidence of this at the end of the final battle at the novel's end. And this sets the scene for the continuation of this mandate in the next instalment. 

This is allegorical for fallen man in the Bible and what we are experiencing today. In this novel, the Knights to me represent the members of the Church with our mandate of the Great Commission in Matthew 28:16-20, 

The 11 disciples traveled to Galilee, to the mountain where Jesus had directed them. When they saw Him, they worshiped, but some doubted. Then Jesus came near and said to them, “All authority has been given to Me in heaven and on earth. Go, therefore, and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, teaching them to observe everything I have commanded you. And remember, I am with you always, to the end of the age.”

The Spiritswords represent the Holy Spirit and the power of His Word and His presence in our lives. The rebellious nature of the warring factions the Knights are mandated to bring peace and restoration to represent the various nationalities of our world and how our sin and rebellion against our High King has resulted in wars, greed and selfishness towards each other and God.

Armstrong has demonstrated well in this novel that Christians are to be a light in a dark world beset with darkness from those forces in direct opposition to the High King. The Knights are representative of this. One way, amongst others, is when Anargen stands up to the Ordumair authorities and their Thane about the spiritual origins of the plight and war they are now engaged in and that the only way for them be free of the spiritual oppression and dominion this war threatened them with was to repent of their rebellious ways against the High King they used to serve in their heritage. 

This novel I enjoyed and appreciated more than I thought I would, which is not an offence to this author. It is engaging, addictive and uplifting. It not only entertained me, but it encouraged my faith in my High King and reinforces the reason Christians are to be a light unto fallen mankind and the mandate of the Great Commission. 

Highly Recommended.

If you would like to investigate this novel further, click on the image below:


Readers and reviews are an author’s best asset, so I encourage any reader, to consider reading The Gathering Dark and submit a review on Goodreads, Amazon, Barnes and Noble and on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest (or any other social media you subscribe to).

Reviews help promote an author’s novel to potential readers and encourage the author to keep writing. Reviews also help get the author’s message (and God’s message) to the reader, whether Christian or not, who may need encouragement and support in their lives while being entertained by the story.

Please note that as an Amazon Associate, I am required to disclose that book cover images or titles of novels in this post are paid links if they are linked to Amazon and result in a sale.

Monday, 8 August 2022

Novel Review: The Mindruler (The Mindrulers, Book 1) by Steve Pillinger.

I reviewed this novel on 14/07/20 in a previous blog I had, now defunct.

The Mindruler, (The Mindrulers, Book 1).

A student, a lecturer, a web designer, a retired teacher: four unlikely strangers suddenly find themselves in an unknown country on an unknown world, their ears assaulted by the clash of swords on armour and the whizz of arrows. Caught up in a mediaeval battle, Steve, Gil, Lannie and Denise are rescued by the losing side and hustled to the dubious safety of a basement in a burnt-out castle.

Here they learn that their hosts—people not unlike themselves—are the only survivors of a rebellion against the vicious regime of Mindruler Shambor dom Beldet and his country-wide network of Mindbenders. These brutal overlords have mastered telepathy to the point where they can invade people’s thoughts and control their lives. Their eyes and ears are everywhere.

But in the last free community in the castle basement, the new arrivals are hailed as the long-awaited “Restorers of the Way”—the “strangers and loners” of prophecy, who will overthrow Shambor and bring peace and freedom to the tormented land of Dûrion. The foreigners find this idea ludicrous. How can they, four ordinary people, pose as revolutionaries in a country they don’t even know?

Captured, enslaved, barely escaping, betrayed by one of their own, they are pursued across the country from one precarious refuge to the next by a tyrant bent on their destruction. En route they find friends and helpers in unexpected places, along with other powerful resources—resources the tyrant cannot control.

Even so, how can they succeed against his all-pervasive network of mentally-controlled slaves? Can the God they call upon overcome even the Mindruler’s unimaginable powers? Are they truly the long-awaited Restorers, who will end his tyranny and set the suffering people of Dûrion free?

The first of three novels in The Mindrulers series, this book is written by a linguist with significant cross-cultural experience and a love of history. It is set in a richly-imagined world featuring convincing languages, fascinating cultures, and meticulously detailed maps of the characters’ journeys. The setting is thoroughly worked out, creating an inner consistency and a breadth of history and geography that gives the reader a sense of reality, and of hidden vistas that may yet open up.

Perspective by Peter:

When I read the description for this novel and read some of the reviews, I had an impression that this would be a great read. I have not been disappointed. In fact, this novel has exceeded this impression. It looks like the remaining two novels will be the same or better and culminate in this series being memorable and placed up there in one's list of favourite novels/series, the author as well.

This novel is very absorbing and immersive. Just how I love it. Others novels have done this to me but this novel is one in a small minority where I have become totally removed from my reality. This occurred at 630 am before work, at lunchtime and at 9 pm before bedtime and at all those times, I was unaware of my surroundings. I was transported to the land of Dûrion. So many times, after reading this novel, I found it hard to return to the stark reality of real-life (starting work, resuming work and sleeping). It was as though I had been transported back and forth between Earth and Dûrion. Honestly, it felt like a mild form of PTSD, but in a positive way, if any positivity can be associated with this disorder!

Steve's background in linguistics, being a master storyteller, his love of history and maps are some of the many pillars that undergird this novel and make it epic fantasy. The foundation of this novel is his love of God's truth and His Gospel that forms a strong and secure foundation that these pillars are embedded. This very much reminds me of the parable to have your house built on a firm foundation and spiritually we need to be founded in God's Truth and a righteous relationship with Him.

This novel is highly imaginative. It is like an onion, there are many layers:

  • Highly entertaining
  • Relational, well developed, three-dimensional characters.
  • Diverse levels of worldbuilding:
    • detailed maps,
    • a Dûrian language with its own sayings/terms and pronunciations,
    • artefacts with supernatural powers implied that these are powered by God seeing they are used by the Restorers chosen by God,
    • people have an aura (shiláy) that is their individual "mental" signature and can be determined whether the person is of has the Light of God in them or not, and if it is the person is a foreigner.
    • A spirituality that is similar to and based on the foundations of Christianity and the Bible, all the tenets of the Bible and Christianity are there but with details changed. This does not detract or change any of the Bible as we know it.
    • A level of evil that is based on Gadesh (evil worldruler, satan in our world), where it is not him or his demons that possess people but these are controlled from their minds being "mindbent" with a mind-altering drug, teméyn. This is virtually the same as being possessed in that, the mindbent person cannot control their actions, movements or exercise their free will as these functions are inactivated from the combination of the drug and a supernatural alteration to the brain's function by the mindruler. They hear his commands in their minds, and if they disobey or need to be punished, the mindruler can inflict severe physical pain or make them in a catatonic state where they are frozen (mindlocked), and in severe pain.
    • People are not the only ones who can talk and have a relationship with God. The Dorbians are a wolf-like creature who talk, and have a human-like similarity in their thinking but are very attuned to the presence of evil as well as those of Light, who are called Lightists, (Christians in our world)
    • In Dûrion, they refer to God as the One, or the One Creator God. Jesus is called Prince or Prince Orrénne.
    • Those who have a relationship with God are called Lightists and those who do not are part of cults of different gods who are under the rule of Gadesh.

There are many more layers and these I have mentioned can be explored deeper in the Appendices at the end of the novel or on Steve's website.

Those who have read The Chronicles of Narnia, will see the similarity here. Instead of children being transported into a foreign land, we have four adults who are transported to another planet, ("...different sky" as described by the Dûrians). Just as the Pevensie siblings were foretold in prophecy that they would break the curse of the land and restore it to its former glory under King Aslan, so too are our four adults to do the same. Now, Pillinger might be criticised for borrowing this from Lewis but I feel the differences overturn this criticism. For a start, the Pevensie children were transported by accident (by venturing into the wardrobe by curiosity on Lucy and Edmund's part and then the all of them to hide from the overbearing housekeeper) whereas our four adults in this novel are transported upon their willingness to confront their shortcomings (...in a "different place") as a challenge from Father Martin, who seems to be so intuned to God and sees each individual's failing as God sees them.

It was through the four main characters from this "different sky" testimonies of how they arrived in Dûrion that led me to consider that is Father Martin just a minister who has a unique understanding of man's fallen nature and in tune with God or is he either an Angel sent from God to challenge people to confront their failings or is he Jesus in this form to do the same thing? I would love for Pillinger to develop this further. It could well be a great prequel novella or full-length novel in this Mindrulers world. There is also future scope for the same in developing the character and history of James Turner who was a previous resident of Earth who had been sent to Dûrion in its founding years. How did he get there hundreds of years earlier? Was there a Father Martin type character, or was it the Angel or Jesus in a person of this time period doing the same thing as experienced by Steve, Lannie, Gid and Denise? I discussed this with the author and he is not averse to this, but again, with all authors, it comes down to time, circumstance, and the desire to go there. For reader's sakes and those who love this trilogy, I sincerely hope he does. I feel it needs to be told!

And here is another similarity to The Chronicles of Narnia. The Professor in The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe had been to Narnia as he built the Wardrobe with wood from Narnia and inscribed all the symbols and events from his stay there on the doors and side of it. So James Turner is likened to this here. He left relics for the next visitors to use in their quest, that the Restorers are now benefitting from.

And this is as far as any further comparison to Lewis's Narnia series I will go as this review is not a comparison of the two stories despite these similarities.

I read that another reviewer said that this novel is not a character-driven one but rather a plot-driven. However, I see Pillinger having a healthy balance of the two. And this is another strength of this novel. When too much attention and development is on the plot and not the characters, the latter become two dimensional or less and very unrelatable with little or no connection from the reader to these characters and the reader gets swept along with the pace and action of the plot. When the development swings too much on the character side, the reader can become frustrated with them and end up wanting to inflict some not very nice things on them. In this case, it can be seen as if the characters do not matter, they are of secondary importance.

However, Pillinger must have been aware of this as his balance is well-done. This series is based on the four characters being sent to Dûrion to confront and overcome their failings in various aspects of their lives and so the focus has to be on this as they venture into the world of Dûrion and the obstacles they face in completing their mission of becoming the prophesied Restorers and in the process, overcoming their failings and become a better version of themselves, albeit one that is more of God and less of themselves.

And in depicting this, the plot has to not overtake the plot arcs involving the characters. Pillinger has intertwined both. The action scenes and obstacles they face are also platforms for them to learn about their failings and develop themselves so that upon their return to Earth they have become overcomers and have a stronger relationship with God and as I mentioned before, more of God and less of them. This is Biblical as this touches on why we suffer in this world. Overcoming our failings by focussing on God, being obedient to what He wants us to do and allowing Him to change us, gives glory to Him, is a witness to who He is and what He can do in an individual's life. It also shows sin for what it is and the snare of the evil one. We see this in The Mindruler. Each of the four Restorers by the end of the novel is changed for the better, not as enslaved to their failing with more evidence an improvement and change appearing. I am sure their transformation is complete by the third novel, The Strongholder. And I am sure there is a little (or maybe a lot!) of ourselves that we can identify in each of the four Restorers. This is another way we relate to them.

I have read discussions amongst Christians who don't believe that God has/could create life on other planets and who died for them as well. But this presumes that a created being on that planet has sinned and then has a fallen nature and is therefore short of God's glory just like mankind as we know on earth. But it definitely falls into the speculative side of it where the question is raised what if.... (there were other created beings on other created worlds by God who have sinned and Christ died for them as well. Would the death he died once for all as recorded in the Bible be for them as well?). Pillinger has this premise in this trilogy and it is the main plot arc he has developed.

Sometimes these speculative endeavours can be a risky thing in a novel as it tends to polarise the reader and some may then not finish (but still write a scathing review and almost character assassinate the poor author!) and then go about telling all their fellow Christians not to read anything from this author and he needs deliverance from the spirit of heresy! Maybe an exaggeration but I am sure some would do this, human nature being what it is. However, it cannot be denied that Pillinger has done this well in this novel (and if this novel is any indication, the rest of the trilogy as well). Putting aside this setting of salvation, redemption and spiral into evil on another God-created world, this novel (and trilogy) does show how fallen man can overcome their sinful nature and individual sin by a relationship with God and living out His Word (Bible). I found the example here of Lannie applying the Word of God to her being in her mindlocked state to be an effective one. It showed the power of the Word in overcoming evil and the transformation of her faith in the process. The same can be said for Jomel when she came to the end of herself upon condemnation as a sacrifice to Gadesh and called upon the name of the Lord, He heard her cry of anguish and repentance and gave her the assurance of being delivered.

Pillinger, deliberating or not, has shown what the Body of Christ is like in the four main characters. In Gil, we see how vulnerable someone is to being taken over by evil when there is no relationship with God, in his sinful state. And in order for him to become a Restorer, he would need to be restored to God and this must take place in one of the remaining novels. In the other three who are Christians (or Lightists) in the Dûrian world, we see how each of their talents, abilities work together for the whole in achieving their quest and in becoming more Christ-like in the process. All different but compliment each other.

This novel takes off in action and pace from about the halfway mark and never lets up. This leads to an action-packed finale and sets the scene for the next novel, The Restorers, where this novel is going to become more involved and everything is upped. I was left panting and exhausted by the end of this one. I am rather frustrated as I will be unable to start this second novel straight away as I am scheduled to review another novel by the end of next week so will have to wait until after this.

This is yet another novel that ticks all the boxes of what I like to see in Christian fiction:

  • it has entertained me immensely,
  • it has encouraged my walk with God,
  • it has not deviated from known biblical doctrine, and it will not, I believe, lead a non-believer astray or promote false doctrine,
  • it honours God,
  • it does not encourage worship of the created (eg angels) instead of the Creator (God).

This novel (and by the looks of it, this trilogy) could be considered a Christian classic up there with Lewis and Tolkien, who were instrumental in the creation and development of fantasy as a genre.

This novel has been such a blessing. To bring some of my comments together, this novel is absorbing and immersive, highly imaginative, highly entertaining, encourages your faith and relationship with God, action-packed and fast-paced. It should be regarded as a Christian classic in the calibre of Lewis and Tolkien.

I am so looking forward to the rest of this series.

Highly Recommended.

If you would like to investigate this novel further, click on the image below:


Readers and reviews are an author’s best asset, so I encourage any reader, to consider reading The Mindruler, then submit a review on Goodreads, Amazon, Barnes and Noble and on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest (or any other social media platform you subscribe to).

Reviews help promote an author’s novel to potential readers and encourage the author to keep writing. Reviews also help get the author’s message (and God’s message) to the reader, who may need encouragement and support in their lives while being entertained by the story.

Please note: As an Amazon Associate, I am required to disclose that book cover images or titles of novels in this post are paid links if they are linked to Amazon and result in a sale.